ICLR Reviewers Discuss How to Critique AI Writing

An ICLR reviewer shared an incomprehensible paper abstract on Reddit, questioning how to critique AI-assisted writing. They noted that simply calling it 'clearly AI writing' is not appropriate, as AI editing is allowed, and critiques should focus on the substantive problems of the writing itself.

• Reviewers complain ICLR and AAMAS submissions are very low quality2026-10-19
• ICLR 2027 Reciprocal Reviewer Has No Paper Assignments2026-10-18
• ICLR Reviewer Laments Desk Rejections2026-10-16
• Reviewer Finds Three ICLR Submissions Likely AI-Generated2026-10-14
• Community Discusses How to Write Top-Conference Papers2026-10-14